Peanut butter and jelly mayonnaise burger

Peanut butter and jelly mayonnaise burger—it sounds wild, right? I thought so too until a midnight fridge raid led me to slap these together on a burger patty. The result? Unexpectedly amazing. That accidental bite sparked a curiosity I couldn’t ignore.

In this guide, I’ll walk you through the story behind this quirky creation, the key ingredients, how to make it, how to serve it, and why it’s more than just a novelty. If you’re craving something bold and unforgettable, this burger might just be your next kitchen obsession.

Table of Contents

1. Definition and History of Peanut Butter and Jelly Mayonnaise Burger

The peanut butter and jelly mayonnaise burger is a bold twist on the classic American burger, combining sweet, salty, tangy, and savory in one bite. While the exact origin is unclear, it likely emerged from the experimental food scene in the U.S., where unconventional mashups often become cult favorites. Learn more about the history of burgers and how innovation has shaped surprising creations like this one.

Originally seen as a novelty or late-night creation, it’s now gaining traction among foodies and gourmet burger joints. The odd-sounding blend of peanut butter, jelly, and mayo works surprisingly well, offering creamy texture, sweetness, acidity, and umami all at once—a flavor combination that challenges the rules but rewards the brave.

2. Ingredients of Peanut Butter and Jelly Mayonnaise Burger

To make this flavor-packed burger, you’ll need:

Ingredient	Quantity	Substitute
Ground beef patty	1 (4–6 oz)	Plant-based patty
Peanut butter	1 tbsp	Almond or cashew butter
Grape jelly	1 tbsp	Strawberry or fig jam
Mayonnaise	1 tbsp	Vegan mayo or aioli
Burger bun	1	Brioche or gluten-free

These ingredients create the unique sweet, salty, and creamy balance that defines the peanut butter and jelly mayonnaise burger.

For a deeper dive into the nutrition side of this dish, check out the health benefits of natural peanut butter.

3. Instructions on How to Cook Peanut Butter and Jelly Mayonnaise Burger

Follow these quick steps:

Step 1: Season and grill or pan-fry the beef patty until cooked to your desired doneness.
Step 2: Lightly toast the burger bun for added texture.
Step 3: Spread peanut butter on the bottom bun and jelly on the top bun.
Step 4: Add a layer of mayonnaise directly on the patty or on the bun for extra creaminess.

Pro Tip: Use crunchy peanut butter for added texture, or mix the mayo with sriracha for a spicy kick.

Looking for variations? Try this fun take on a PBJ burger.

4. How to Serve Peanut Butter and Jelly Mayonnaise Burger

This burger can be styled up or down:

• Formal twist: Serve with sweet potato fries and a dill pickle spear.
• Casual vibe: Pair it with classic potato chips or coleslaw.
• Garnish idea: Add sliced banana peppers or crispy bacon for extra depth.
• Drink pairing: A craft root beer or a nutty brown ale complements the sweet-savory combo.

However you serve it, this burger is sure to spark conversation—and cravings.

Need ideas for sides? Check out our guide to burger and fries combinations.

5. General Benefits of Peanut Butter and Jelly Mayonnaise Burger

Surprisingly, this indulgent burger offers a few health perks when made with quality ingredients:

• Protein boost: The beef patty and peanut butter provide a solid dose of protein.
• Healthy fats: Peanut butter and mayo (especially olive-oil-based) contribute heart-friendly fats.
• Energy source: The jelly adds quick carbs, making this burger a good post-workout refuel.
• Mood food: The rich, sweet-savory combo can satisfy cravings and boost serotonin levels.

Moderation is key, but this burger can be a fun way to enjoy both flavor and function.

Compare this to another indulgent-yet-elevated option like the truffle smash burger.

6. FAQs About Peanut Butter and Jelly Mayonnaise Burger

Want to level up your sauces? Discover what goes into the special sauce on the hangover burger.

Conclusion

The peanut butter and jelly mayonnaise burger isn’t just a quirky food trend—it’s a bold culinary adventure. From its curious origins to its surprisingly balanced ingredients, this burger proves that unexpected combinations can create unforgettable flavors. With simple steps, flexible serving ideas, and even a few nutritional perks, it’s a dish worth trying at least once.

Whether you’re hosting friends or just feeding your own curiosity, give this burger a shot. And don’t be surprised if it ends up becoming a guilty favorite. Share it, tweak it, and enjoy the ride—because food should always be a little fun.

If this burger sparked your interest, you’ll also love exploring other popular burger styles to expand your flavor horizons.

Print

For more just follow tasty recipes on our Facebook and Instagram!